Paul Ryan’s Health Insurance Seminar Proves One Thing: He Has No Friggin’ Idea How Insurance Works

Thursday morning Republicans rolled out a presentation of their long-awaited alternative to the Affordable Care Act (aka ObamaCare). It came in the form of a lecture by Speaker of the House Paul Ryan. He stood before the class and gave a PowerPoint aided speech that supposedly spelled out everything you might need to know about the GOP plan.

Paul Ryan

There was just one problem. Well actually, way more than one. But in the broadest terms the single most problematic part of Ryan’s lecture was that it made no sense whatsoever. It failed to address how it would cover everyone who is presently covered. There were no financing specifics to explain how it would be funded. But the most prominent flaw in his presentation was that it revealed that he has no idea what insurance is. Nor does he have any notion of how it works. Ryan summed up his criticism of ObamaCare saying that:

“The whole idea of Obamacare is … the people who are healthy pay for the people who are sick. It’s not working, and that’s why it’s in a death spiral.”

Let that sink in. What Ryan is saying is not that ObamaCare doesn’t work, but that the whole concept of insurance doesn’t work. Every insurance product, whether it’s for healthcare or auto accidents, operates on the same principle. Many people pay into a pool that is used to cover the costs of the unfortunates who suffer a loss. Insurance depends on the fact that most policy holders will not have a claim (i.e. healthy people). Therefore, their premiums pay for folks who do have claims (i.e. the sick or injured).

Paul Ryan doesn’t seem to grasp that concept. To demonstrate the depth of his confusion, he offered a little example:

[Video below, starts at 14:30]: “Take a small business that has forty employees. Let’s say that four people in that business get cancer. Well, under that business, that business has to pay for all those cancer patients, all those cancer treatments. So the other thirty-six people in that forty person pool get hit with much, much higher premiums to pay for the four that got cancer. That’s how the insurance works today. And that is one of the reasons why this thing is going bankrupt.

“Here’s our solution. Let’s just make sure we cover the people who have preexisting conditions. Make sure reinsurance or risk pools kick in for those four people in that small business that get cancer. Subsidize that coverage and what you do by doing that is you dramatically lower and stabilize the price of insurance for everybody else.”

Let’s break that down. Ryan says that the practice of insuring people by having many people contribute to a risk pool is going bankrupt. He might want to run that by the multi-billion dollar, highly profitable insurance corporations for confirmation. Then he proposes that only the sick people get federally subsidized insurance. That leaves the population of healthy people with lower premiums. That’s actually true. And it makes the insurance companies wealthier because they are only covering people who don’t need any coverage.

But Ryan doesn’t say where the government would get the money to pay for the cancer patients in his scenario. Ordinarily those funds would come from the healthy people that he just removed from the picture.

So one of three things would happen. Either the government would have to bear the total cost of healthcare for America’s sickest population and incur massive debts. Or everyone would have to be taxed to finance the coverage for those patients. Or the sick people would just die. Ironically, there is a germ of a real solution in there. Universal healthcare would provide all Americans with coverage and spread the costs so broadly across the populace that the premiums would be easily manageable.

But that’s not what Ryan and company are proposing. They want to give all the healthy people cheap insurance and burden the sick with unpayable bills. That’s the solution that is being advanced by Republicans in Congress and has already been endorsed by President Trump. If you have the intestinal fortitude, you can watch the entire presentation by Ryan and see if it makes any sense to you. If not, stay away because intestinal maladies are not covered in the GOP plan.

How Fox News Deceives and Controls Their Flock:
Fox Nation vs. Reality: The Fox News Cult of Ignorance.
Available now at Amazon.


9 thoughts on “Paul Ryan’s Health Insurance Seminar Proves One Thing: He Has No Friggin’ Idea How Insurance Works

  1. I am beginning to think that I am in bizzaro world. A president who was never in politics, with a cabinet and advisors who hate their departments or government in general, and a Speaker of the House who doesn’t understand what he is doing, mostly led by a party that got fewer votes.

  2. I am stunned by the Speaker’s ignorance, stunned but not surprised. He has a great little smile or smirk and no brains behind it. Knowing he is from Wisconsin, the land of the equally ignorant Scott Walker, he seems old enough to have benefited from a good education, which Wisconsin once provided before Walker cut funding to its university system–too many liberals on the faculties. But both me must have slept through class or were smoking weed behind the gym. As my late mother would say, “When the lord passed out the brains, Ryan–and Walker–thought he said TRAINS and they missed theirs.” Denny Hastert molested little boys. Ryan molests American poor and elderly.

  3. ReThuglican Plan for Replacing Obamacare:

    1) Convince everyone that Obamacare is a total failure, even though there’s ample evidence that it isn’t.
    2) Blame Obama.
    3) Dither about what to do.
    4) Blame Obama.
    5) Attempt to defund it and fail miserably.
    6) Blame Obama.
    7) Create something that is the exact same fricking thing! but call it something else.
    8) Blame Obama.
    9) Blame the press when it figures out that it IS the exact same fricking thing!
    10) Blame Obama.
    11) Mass produce Trump Energy Bars.
    12) Give a massive tax break to Big Pharma for no reason.
    13) Blame Obama.

    And did I leave out “Blame Obama”? 🙂

  4. while I agree Ryan’s overall idea is flawed he had some good points for example he is right about health insurance premiums going up, and fewer choices in health care. the system doesn’t work if no one can afford to buy health care in the first place. If we could manage to get full coverage health plans down to 100-200 a month everyone could afford it.

    • Health insurance premiums and deductibles were skyrocketing before the ACA. Those were two reasons people were clamoring for change.
      Single payer is the ONLY way we can get health care costs down to a reasonable price.

  5. What we have here is the best example of the trump/Ryan death care bill. Not healthcare you see but deathcare. How many millions will die till those miserable, hateful scumbags are kicked out and people who actually care about the people of this country!

  6. If you impeach Trump you get to Pence who wouldn’t be any sort of upgrade. If you then impeached Pence I would submit that you would probably be worse off with Ryan than you were when you started.

    • All of the arguments against impeaching Trump because of who would succeed him fall flat with me. It goes without saying that all of the top Republicans suck. But I’d rather have any of them than a total maniac.

  7. Mark, all of the Republicans would be terrible choices for president. Pence is dedicated to creating a theocracy. Ryan is devoted to creating an oligarchy of the rich.
    With Trump we at least get some form of governmental gridlock because Bannon is dedicated to Armageddon, which even most Republicans are against.

Comments are closed.