Cliven Bundy’s Racist (On Video) Rant Is Nothing New For Conservatives Who Praise Slavery

America’s most notorious welfare rancher and domestic terrorist, Cliven Bundy, has revealed more about himself and his repugnant ideology. In an interview with the New York Times (video below), Bundy volunteers a bit of his prairie wisdom concerning the plight of “the negro”:

“I’ve often wondered, are they better off as slaves, picking cotton and having a family life and doing things, or are they better off under government subsidy? They didn’t get no more freedom. They got less freedom.”

Exactly! Because who wouldn’t prefer being chained up and forced to work for no pay while being beaten, raped, and traded like the cattle that Bundy grazes illegally on land upon which he is trespassing?

Cliven Bundy

Ever since the Bundy affair became a cause celebre for conservative politicians and pundits, Tea Party and militia types have been heralding Bundy as a patriot and a hero for threatening to shoot fellow Americans who were performing their duties as law enforcement officers. It was only a matter of time before his revolt revealed just how revolting he really is. As a result, many of the people who were lauding him yesterday are backpedaling as fast as they can to disassociate themselves from Bundy today.

Rand Paul called Bundy’s remarks “offensive.” Nevada Sen. Dean Heller condemned them as “appalling and racist.” Republican National Committee chairman Reince Priebus said it was “beyond the pale” and “100% wrong on race.” Not surprisingly, Bundy’s BFF, Sean Hannity, has yet to comment on this turn of events. While it is commendable that some Republican leaders found the moral gumption to denounce this overt expression of racism, it’s interesting that they had no problem with any of this when it was merely an articulated threat to kill federal agents while using women and children as human shields.

Unfortunately, this newly discovered discomfort with hate speech rings hollow when viewed in the totality of the conservative mindset. In October of 2012, I wrote an article on “American Conservatives Who Still Think That Slavery Was A Good Thing.” It unveiled ten prominent right-wingers who feel exactly the way Bundy does. The list includes conservative icons like Pat Buchanan, Michele Bachmann, and Ann Coulter, explaining why African-Americans were better off as slaves. Nobody was denouncing these racists for their hateful outbursts at the time. So it’s hard to accept that they are genuinely disturbed by these recent comments when the same rancid bigotry is so much a part of their political character. Here are the ten slavery advocates from the article:

1) Pat Buchanan
In his essay “A Brief for Whitey,” Buchanan agreed that slavery was a net positive saying that, “America has been the best country on earth for black folks. It was here that 600,000 black people, brought from Africa in slave ships, grew into a community of 40 million, were introduced to Christian salvation, and reached the greatest levels of freedom and prosperity blacks have ever known.”

2 & 3) Michele Bachmann and Rick Santorum
Bob Vander Plaats, the leader of the arch-conservative Family Leader, a religious organization that opposes same-sex marriage, got GOP presidential candidates Bachmann and Santorum to sign his pledge asserting that life for African-Americans was better during the era of slavery: “A child born into slavery in 1860 was more likely to be raised by his mother and father in a two-parent household than was an African American baby born after the election of the USA’s first African-American President.”

4) Art Robinson
Robinson was a publisher and a GOP candidate for congress in Oregon. One of the books he published included this evaluation of life under slavery: “The negroes on a well-ordered estate, under kind masters, were probably a happier class of people than the laborers upon any estate in Europe.”

5) Rev. Jesse Lee Peterson
Peterson is a conservative preacher who articulated this bit of gratitude: “Thank God for slavery, because if not, the blacks who are here would have been stuck in Africa.”

6) David Horowitz
Horowitz is the president of the David Horowitz Freedom Center and edits the ultra-conservative FrontPage Magazine. In a diatribe against reparations for slavery, Horowitz thought this argument celebrating the luxurious life of blacks in America would bolster his case: “If slave labor created wealth for Americans, then obviously it has created wealth for black Americans as well, including the descendants of slaves.”

7) Wes Riddle
Riddle was a GOP congressional candidate in Texas with some peculiar conspiracy theories on a variety of subjects. His appreciation for what slavery did for African-Americans was captured in this comment: “Are the descendants of slaves really worse off? Would Jesse Jackson be better off living in Uganda?”

8) Trent Franks
Franks is the sitting congressman for the 2nd congressional district in Arizona. As shown here, he believes that a comparison of the tribulations of African-Americans today to those of their ancestors in the Confederacy would favor a life in bondage: “Far more of the African American community is being devastated by the policies of today than were being devastated by the policies of slavery.”

9) Ann Coulter
Known for her incendiary rhetoric and hate speech, Coulter was right in character telling Megyn Kelly of Fox News that, “The worst thing that was done to black people since slavery was the great society programs.”

10) Rep. Loy Mauch
This Arkansas GOP state legislator has found biblical support for his pro-slavery position. He wrote to the Democrat-Gazette to inquire, “If slavery were so God-awful, why didn’t Jesus or Paul condemn it, why was it in the Constitution and why wasn’t there a war before 1861?”

Shameless self-promotion…
Get Fox Nation vs. Reality. Available now at Amazon.

That was two years ago. Since then Tea Party types like Ted Nugent, Ben Carson, and Duck Dynasty’s Phil Robertson have joined their ranks. For Cliven Bundy to criticize African-Americans as lazy moochers on government subsidies while he is exploiting government subsidized land that he refuses to pay for, is monumentally hypocritical. And the right-wing enablers of his criminality should be ashamed of ever having supported him.

[Update] On his radio program today, Hannity finally weighed in saying that Bundy’s “comments are beyond repugnant to me. They are beyond despicable to me. They are beyond ignorant to me. […] People who, for the right reasons, saw this as government overreach are now branded because of the ignorant, racist, repugnant, despicable comments by Cliven Bundy.”

So Hannity is more “pissed off” for the poor branded wingnuts (i.e. himself) who encourage terrorism, rather than the actual victims of racial hatred. What’s more, Hannity spent more time condemning liberals for a false equivalency on racism than he did rebuking Bundy.

Also, Bundy held a press conference of sorts wherein he actually doubled down on his offensive views regarding African-Americans and whether they might have been happier as slaves.


9 thoughts on “Cliven Bundy’s Racist (On Video) Rant Is Nothing New For Conservatives Who Praise Slavery

  1. I can’t wait for Sean Hannity’s response to what his new friend has said. Now remember that he considers President Obama to be fully responsible for everything everyone he has ever associated with has said about anything. I don’t think we can expect Hannity to apply that same standard to himself. He probably will act as though he has never heard of the guy and never mention him again! We know he is not capable of any kind of shame or self-examination of his demented views.

  2. SOMEONE PLEASE – have MSNBC, or CNN, or CBS, or hell even ABC news, go do a quick one to two question interview with ALL the other ranchers that pay their grazing fees. Do a, do you use the land? Yes. Do you pay the grazing fees? Yes… cut to next person, same questions… do that for many if not all. Then at the end ask one question to audience… Why don’t Bundy pay like every other law biding citizen?

    I wish he would stop the “this is my family’s land” BS. It may have been way back when, but someone sold it off, which was prob him to begin with, because the wanted the money. So, sold land means not yours or your family’s land. Saying it is yours does not make it true.

  3. The politicians who have been supporting him are backpedaling at the moment. His supporters however will still support him & start screaming about freedom of speech. They’ll stand up for his right to believe whatever he wants to. Mostly because so many of them believe the same thing.

  4. If Ailes needed an excuse to get rid of Hannity, he just had one fall into his lap. We are about to see what Ailes is made of.

    I also find it ironic that Sen Heller, NV, (and his ilk) while calling Bundy a “patriot” one day, is forced to call him “appalling and racists” the next. However, he knows that time will heal all ills and his supporters will forget or not care.

    And the rightwing of this country STILL can’t understand why they are the laughing stock they have become. And lets be honest, who is really surprised these are Bundys’ views? Those on the right who say they are surprised are being disingenuous or have their heads in the sand. For those of us who grew up in the middle of it knew it was just a matter of time. If it weren’t so prevalent on the right, it would be funny.

  5. I suppose that I really didn’t recognize the validity of George Bushes’ government since I thought their lack of ability to prevent 911 bordered on the criminal and attacking Iraq on made-up evidence of mass destruction threats was criminal by any standards. I also felt that his election was questionable since it was facilitated by the Supreme Court rather then the electoral college but I never felt that I had the right to individually renounce that government. Of course I didn’t have a financial interest in renouncing the federal government like Mr Bundy.

  6. Of course conservatives love slavery … for others. That’s why they are active work to enslave the middle class and keep the spoils for themselves. That is why they were gleeful during the government shutdown (they caused) at the prospect of federal employees forced to work for free. They actively work to destabilize our government, which always inflicts harm on the most vulnerable in society.

  7. Notice that Sean Innanity says that the COMMENT is despicable, but does not say the man making the comment is despicable –very important distinction lost on most people

  8. I find it odd that Republicans distance themselves from Mr. Bundy when he exercises his free speech but approve when he practices the equivalent of welfare fraud for twenty years. They must be courting the African-American vote again.

Comments are closed.